Click on the picture to get to our home page,
Books and Videos for Dog Lovers

K9joy Education

Teaching the Dog English…?

From the desk of Mogens Eliasen - first published: April 25, 2006



Mogens Eliasen - the author of this article
on 'Teaching the Dog English…?'

In English-speaking countries, it has long been tradition to use standard commands for dogs that are common daily English words. The advantage, of course, is that the owner then does not have to bother learning anything new here, but can safely rely on his/her already well-consolidated understanding of his/her mother-tongue, right?

Or is there more to this?

First some facts

Dogs can learn to differentiate words that are very close to each other, like Hop, Cop, and Top, as long as those words mean different kinds of action from the dog’s side. It is far from simple, though – because it really takes a lot of training overcoming confusion before the dog learns to pay attention to those subtle differences. In other words, you are tremendously increasing your own workload in your training program by making such choices for commands…

Dogs do not have the linguistic capabilities as humans and monkeys do to associate words with objects and things. Dogs can, in principle, only learn to understand verbs, because verbs mean action. Dogs learn primarily from their own action, extremely rarely from watching others. Sometimes, people kid themselves into believing differently. When a dog learns the difference between two commands like, “My shoes” and “The paper” it is tempting to think that the dog understands the difference between the names “shoes” and “paper”. But that’s not the case. The dog understands the difference between “fetching the shoes” and “fetching the paper” – two different kinds of hunting action.

Dogs are good at reading human minds, and they are good at paying attention to tone of voice, the pitch of the voice, the rhythm of words, the intonation, etc. So, in principle and in practice, dogs can indeed learn the difference between “stay down!”, “get down from there!”, “lie down!” But it is not at all a simple training task to get the dog to understand those three different meanings of “down”, compared to teaching the dog the same three performances on three commands that were more non-similar.

On top of this, the dog also needs to learn to ignore all other daily uses of the word “down” that are not meant as commands to the dog, but as part of some communication with other people…. In other words, dogs can indeed learn when to ignore the word “down” when it is part of such human-to-human communication and when the word signals a command for action to the dog. There is a lot of serious training involved in this, though – it is absolutely not taught in “just a few weeks”, not even by the best of dog trainers.

Dogs can learn about 50 different commands. Most training programs make do with 20-30. Humans typically learn about 2,000 before they are 3 years old.


Adding some human brain power…

I am just curious about this: wouldn’t it be smart, particularly for a novice dog trainer that does not have a lot of experience training dogs, to aim at making the training task as easy as possible for the dog? After all, humans have far superior intelligence to dogs, so trying to complicate a training task for the dog in order to save self for some inconvenience that is easily overcome does not make any sense…

Let me be specific: Given the dog’s learning capabilities and a human’s learning capabilities, what do you think goes faster:

  1. Teaching the dog the subtle difference between three almost identical command words, plus the difference between those three and all the other possible daily uses of that same word in contexts that are not related to the dog and thus should be ignored?

  2. For the person to learn three new words that are not part of daily language used in person-to-person communications?

I am not trying to insult your intelligence. In standard obedience training in English-speaking countries, it is the rule to prefer A to B!

The result, of course, is that the training takes much longer time – and maybe it never is successful! For no other reason than this ridiculous attempt to make things more complicated for the dog in order to save self from a very minor extra challenge to the human intelligence. Sorry, but it is a ludicrous concept.


Selecting command words that make sense

The solution is obvious to any intelligent person: choose command words that are easy for the dog to recognize and to differentiate from human-to-human communications!

Kids know how to do this: they all have a time in their lives where they speak “code language” to each other.

Military operations often depend on the same principle. All US soldiers knew what “Desert Storm” meant – before the action in Kuwait.

There is no difference for the human-to-dog communication. It needs to be precise and well-defined, with no risks of confusion. Otherwise, it will be an extra burden on the dog, and it will take significantly longer time to train a reliable response to the command from the dog’s side. Besides, such confusion in the learning process will seriously affect the whole relationship between dog and owner!

In other words: choosing dog commands to be commonly used words from the language you use when communicating with other people is sabotaging your own training efforts! Your best bet is to invent some artificial made-up code words that you would never use for anything else. Sure, if you have no knowledge of Chinese, make them “Chinese”. The dog doesn’t care…


The excuses…

Yes, I know all the common excuses from people who plain simply refuse to pick their commands this way. The most common one is, “but how am I to remember all those different command words?”

First a comment, then the answer. The comment is this: “If you, with your superior intelligence and ability to learn language, are unable to remember those command words, how on Earth can you then expect your dog to do that?”

The answer is this: For the dog to learn a new command, you need to instigate some systematic training. You will have to do some 10-50 repetition of the training sequence for that commands every day – and you will have to do that for a few weeks! If you do not know that command verbatim by then, you should not even think about training a dog…

I have often seen this illustrated in my training classes: Some students come to the second class, one week after the first, and were supposed to be doing homework, training the exercises we went through last week, a minimum of 10 times each every day. I do not even need to see their training in order to tell if they did their homework or not. And I do not need to ask them. Those who have to consult their notes before they can show me what they have taught the dog did not do their homework – they don’t remember their own commands!

If you trained 10 times a day for a week, you will know that word so well that you have no need for consulting any notes in order to remember it.

I believe you can make your own appropriate conclusion from this.


Sincerely,

Mogens Eliasen


-------------------------------------------

Mogens Eliasen holds a mag. scient. degree (comparable to a US Ph. D.) in Chemistry from Ĺrhus University, Denmark, has a extensive education also as military officer and in business management. He has been working with dogs, dog owners, dog trainers, and veterinarians since 1970. A large part of his dog work has been in the area of education and education planning, and as consultant for dog owners and dog training associations. He is a strong advocate of treating the dog with respect for its nature as domesticated wolf, and has published several books and videos on topics related to dogs, dog training, dog behavior, and responsible care of dogs. He publishes a newsletter "The Peeing Post" containing lots of tips and advice on all matters pertaining to dogs.

For more information about Mogens Eliasen, including links to other articles he has published, please send this e-mail to or visit www.k9joy.com or mogenseliasen.com.



The article above may be copied and published as is, when it includes the bio at the end and is not subject to commerce.

The permission to copy and publish this article particularly encompasses:

  • You may print out the PDF version and copy it and distribute it to other people, as long as you do not charge money for those copies. (Link opens in separate window.)

  • You may create a TXT document on the basis of the PDF document, as long as you respect the overall formatting as closely as possible and do not alter the contents.

You are granted up-front permission to publish this article as outlined above, without first asking. We would appreciate if you would give us your feedback on it and tell us about where you distribute it - and possibly also later let us know what kind of responses you got.

The URL for it is http://k9joy.com/dogarticles/commands.php

The stats for this article are:
   Number of pages (PDF version): 3
   Number of lines (TXT version): 183
   Line length (TXT version): maximum 63 characters
   Total characters (including spaces, line shifts, etc.): 6,444
   Total printing characters: 7,854
   Total word count: 1,318
   Flesh-Kincaid Grade Level: 9.6



Other articles of Mogens Eliasen are available from http://k9joy.com/dogarticles.



 

Feedback form


Where did you hear about this article?

Comment:


Did the article help you?

Comment:


Would you recommend this article to a friend?

Comment:


How many people are you connected with, who could benefit from this article?

Comment:


What is the nature of your main source of connections to people, who might be interested in this article?

Comment:


Whom will/did you distribute this article to?

(Please check all that apply, and leave blank if you are not going to pass on this article to anyone else.)

Passing on the link through e-mail to personal contacts
Cross-posting it in my on-line newsgroups
Publishing it in my ezine
Printing out copies to some personal contacts
Printing out copies for a special event, where they can be handed out
Printing out copies to be handed out on an on-going basis
Adding a link to it from my web site
Adding it as a separate page to my web site
Other:

Please check here if you already did this:


Any additional comments or suggestions to this article?


Are you a K9joy Affiliate?

Yes No Not yet (Information about our affiliate program at http://k9joy.com/affiliates.)


Are you a subscriber to "The Peeing Post"?

Yes No Not yet (Information about "The Peeing Post" at http://k9joy.com/peeingpost.)


Your first & last name:
Your e-mail address:
(will only be used in case we need to contact you if we should have any questions in regard to clarifying what you mean with your answers...)
Where are you from?
(City/State/Province/Country will suffice)



Looking for something different?

If so, please let us know what you are looking for! We will be happy to take about your ideas and suggestions, and if you are searching for some specific information that we might have available or can create, we will be happy to have your input - and we will notify you of the result.



Titles available from K9joy®:

Anders Hallgren:
"The ABC's of Dog Language" (140 page book - 1996)
Understand what your dog is telling you - and communicate with it on its own terms. A must have for all dog lovers. Easy to read. Easy to use as reference.

Mogens Eliasen:
"The Dog's Social Behavior" (2.5 hr. video - 1998, updated on DVD 2006, with support materials on a CD)
How the dog's behavior is linked to its instincts and needs. What you can change and what is "for life". How you use this information to dramatically improve your relationship with your dog.

Mogens Eliasen:
"BrainWork for Smart Dogs" (380 page e-book - 2003)
How you get a happy and well-behaved dog, stimulating its brain with 15 minutes of fun per day. Dogs need to work and use their instinct in order to be in mental balance. Everyone can do it with these instructions. More than 40 exercises to choose from!

Mogens Eliasen:
"Don't Pull on the Leash!" (40 page e-book - 2005)
The 5 simple steps in this complete training manual will effectively stop any dog from pulling on the leash, with no pain or abuse and no special equipment - and make the start of a much better relationship with the dog.

Mogens Eliasen:
"Is Your Dog's Drinking Water Safe?" (30 page e-book - 2005, updated 2006)
A layman's overview of how and why drinking water gets contaminated - and what you can do about it.

Mogens Eliasen:
"Feeding Your Dog - the Natural Way" (1 hr. video - 1998)
The fastest introduction to get you started on feeding your dog a natural diet. It explains the dog's physiology in simple terms, so you also understand why you should do this.

Mogens Eliasen:
"Canine Choice - by Nature" (80 page e-book - 1999, updated 2005)
The simple "how-to" about feeding a natural diet for optimal health.

Mogens Eliasen:
"Raw Food for Dogs - the Ultimate Reference for Dog Owners"
(340 page e-book - revised/expanded 2006)
Everything you need for making your own informed decisions about what to feed your dog, and why and how. Includes numerous examples of feeding plans plus two chapters on how to work with your vet, also if he/she does not approve of your feeding...

Mogens Eliasen:
"The Wolf's Natural Diet - a Feeding Guide for Your Dog?"
(125 page e-book - 2004 updated/revised 2006)
What we know and don't know about the wolf and its natural feeding, and about the dog and its domestication, and what we can and cannot conclude from wolf to dog... this is the big "why?" behind any responsible approach to feeding your dog.




This site is presented to you by

K9joy®
3980C Riverview Road, Creston, BC, V0B 1G0 Canada
or Box 641, Porthill, Idaho 83853 USA
Phone (Canada, PDT): +1-403-774-7465
(Denmark - evenings, local time): +45 36 98 02 98
Web site: www.k9joy.com

© All rights are reserved by Soverenity Enterprises Inc.
Copying and/or distributing the contents of this web page to other people (also partially),
without prior written consent from us, is prohibited by law.